Can a relationship work without you being in love?
85
Can a relationship work if the people are not in love with each other, or if only one of the two people is in love with the other? I am guessing that most people will immediately clamber on to their soap box and start claiming that there is no future for a relationship where the two people are not in love, and that this is obviously a very unhealthy arrangement. But stop, wait a minute and think this through properly. There are situations where this kind of relationship can work very well. Remember I said 'in love' not 'love', and sometimes love is enough even without the absolute passion of being in love with the person you share your life with.
I have written this article to explore the types of committed relationships where simply being able to say we 'love' the person we are with is enough, and we don't need to be 'in love' (as in the 'old fashioned' sense of the word), in order to see a long and healthy future for the relationship.
Think about marriages of convenience or arranged marriages. In the former case the people are often already good friends, and in the latter case if they don't fall in love with each other over time, they frequently end up loving each other in a way that is unique to the cultures where such marriages are commonplace. We are programmed from an early age to believe in a 'happily ever after' plan for our future lives. The fairy tales we are read as children involve idealistic views of life, where the Prince or Princess of our dreams will end up being our lifelong partner if we try hard enough to find them. The reality is frequently very different, and a vast amount of us end up 'settling' for a partner in life who is not perfect, but is good enough and who we love in a way that is not lifted straight from a fairy tale.
There are various scenarios where a marriage or relationship can work without the two halves of the couple being in love with each other. Imagine for instance a scenario where a mature man has no real interest in a sex life any more, or maybe he has a problem with impotence. He is a comfortably off gentleman who wants an attractive lady on his arm when he attends various functions, and is essentially looking for a companion as opposed to a lover. Then bring into the equation an attractive lady who has medical problems that have effected her libido and ability to work. She is a warm and genuine person who needs security, and he is a lonely man who needs companionship. If these two people hit it off and they grow to love each other as close friends, why would them having a successful relationship be so unlikely? They might marry and live an ideal life as both of them are getting what they need from the relationship in a symbiotic way.
What about a situation where one person is best friends with another? Neither have been lucky in love, but as friends they love each other and in many ways they are soul mates. Would it really be so bad if they were to decide to marry each other or become a long term couple! These two people have loads in common, they know each other inside out, and even if they aren't capable of being passionately in love with each other, they can still love each other to a degree they would each willingly sacrifice their own life to save the other.
Many of us in life met someone once who we will always remember as 'our first true love'. Sadly in most cases this relationship does not work out for all different reasons, one of which is probably our lack of maturity at the time we both meet, (usually in our teens or early twenties). As we go through our lives we have other relationships, but deep down we know the latest person we are seeing is still never going to be 'that first true love'. So what do we do? Well generally we 'settle' for someone who we are either in love with, (but not to the same degree), or someone we deeply care about and love, but are not 'in love' with. Frequently these relationships will last for many years and work well.
There are cases where one partner is 'in love' with the other, but the other person only 'loves' them back. This is not to say that the relationship is a bad one, but just that there are different levels of emotions involved. The latter partner might desperately want to be 'in love' with their partner, but simply cannot feel that way. This is not to say they would ever willingly hurt the other person, and it does not mean they would ever want to be with anyone else. It only means that they cannot quite achieve that depth of feeling for the partner they are with, possibly as a result of previous relationships where they have been hurt very badly and they have now put emotional barriers up to protect themselves against further hurt.
How about a situation where a person is terminally ill. Whether the other person was in love with them or not, so long as they cared enough to not to want to see them die alone, then they are showing them love. If they give them a 'relationship' based on this love for whatever time they have left, then surely this is a good relationship. Probably both of them will accept the fact the marriage or relationship is not based on being 'in love', but each of them has love for the other in their own way, and this is why they get together and stay together until the end.
Just recently I read of a case which was a very sad story. A married woman was diagnosed as terminally ill, (I believe she also had children). Her dying request to her sister was that after she had died she wanted her sister to marry her Husband. Ultimately she passed away, and just last week the sister honoured the dying wish and married her sister's surviving Husband. Now I am sure they are not 'in love' with each other because of the circumstances, but I am also certain they must have love for each other to be able to do this knowing the level of commitment they are making to each other.
There are marriages that are convenient because they allow people from other countries to live in countries they would otherwise not be able to (think green card). Whilst these marriages are sometimes completely fake, there are times when the couple do grow to have a love for each other as time passes. There are even occasions when the love was already there and this is why one partner agrees to help the other out by marrying them so they can remain in the country of their choice.
I have heard of many cases where elderly people have been left alone after their spouses die and decide to marry another elderly person in the same situation. This has been as much for companionship as anything else, and in some cases they were past the stage in their lives where sex was an issue for either of them anyway. Why would they want to spend the rest of their own remaining months or years alone when they could have a friend who they love as their spouse for the rest of their days, someone they could go on holiday with, share a joke with, have a cuddle with and have a good conversation with? They don't have to be passionately in love with each other, all they need is to have enough love for each other that they are compatible.
So this is why I do believe that certain relationships can survive and be healthy even if the couple are not in love with each other. Sometimes simply having love for each other is enough and the all the consuming passion of being madly in love is not essential. It is often said your Husband or Wife should also be your best friend, in some cases they actually are, and that is all they will ever be, but can we honestly say this is always a bad thing and that it cannot work?
Do believe a relationship can work and be happy and healthy without the couple being 'in love' with each other?
See results without votingOther Relevant Articles by Mistyhorizon2003
- How to add some romance into your relationship
Would you like to introduce some romance into your relationship? Do you think your marriage is becoming stale? This article contains suggestions of how to add some romance into your relationships, whether they are new or old, and hopefully ......... - How often do you and your partner have sex....honestly?
How often do you and your partner have sex with each other, honestly? What would you consider a normal amount of times for a couple to have sex when in a long term relationship? How many times do you believe the average couple make love...... - Romantic Ways of How to Propose to your Girlfriend
Finding a romantic way to propose to your girlfriend is a unique challenge, and one you will no doubt want to get right, as hopefully this will be the one and only time you ever need to propose to anybody. This article offer a selection of romantic.. - The Top 10 Passion Killers for Men
Following on from my hub The Top 10 Passion Killers for Women I felt it only right to redress the balance by writing a hub on The Top 10 Passion Killers for Men. After consulting my Husband and some male friends they shared with me their opinions.... - The Top 10 Passion Killers for Women
ust for a bit of fun I thought I would compile a list of the top ten passion killers for women, in other words the things Husbands, boyfriends, lovers or men in general do, that really turn us women off and leave us wanting to run for the hills....
vote upvote downshareprintflag
- Useful (5)
- Funny
- Awesome (6)
- Beautiful (1)
- Interesting (6)
CommentsLoading...
You must have read my Bio on how I am struggling to decide if I should marry the man I love as opposed to waiting to fall "in love" with someone else. This hub has helped me a lot. Thanks.
My husband and I were just discussing this the other day. We've been married for almost 9 years and don't so much feel the "in love" stuff anymore, but have moved into a more comfortable, steady love phase. It's simple and secure with just the right amount of emotion for the place in our life (late 30s & early 40s). We agreed we love it here! :)
Mature - that's the word I was looking for. :)
I'm sort of on the fence about that. I was "in love" with my ex up until he left me for another woman (after 15 years of marriage). It's best to find the level of passion in your mate that mirrors yours. I am a very loving person, and although my ex did not provide my "needs," I still found ways to focus on his good qualities (and remembered the fire that brought us together). We are not all created equal, but after what I've been through, I've realized: life is too short to pour your heart out to someone who can't return the kind of love you can. Anything less, really, is settling. I'd rather stay single from now on than love unconditionally and get "crumbs" of affection in return.
Thanks for posting. Interesting Hub.
Interesting topic, Misty, and well written!
Yes, it is true, the Lone Ranger knows a thing or two about love and has even been "in love", once or twice if memory serves.
Misty, you brought up a lot of good points and I agree with all of them. In fact, studies have shown that cultures where arranged marriages are practiced are less likely to end in divorce and they are less likely to experience the broken-home syndrome that has come to typify those cultures who marry for "love".
One needs to consider that love is a fickle emotion; one that can cease to exist, grow in strength, or change direction as easily as the wind. Therefore, one must nurture love on a consistent and continual basis for it to grow into maturity, in grace and in beauty.
I believe many people place too much stock in the temporary chemical release of Dopamine into the blood stream when they think they are "in love". Most people don't even know about its existence, but it's there.
Research has shown that Dopamine, which is also known as the "love drug", is present for up to four years in any given relationship, but can subside even sooner depending upon circumstances. This chemical makes one's heart beat faster, causes one's pupils to dialate, and makes one feel like they are walking on sunshine whenever the object of affection is near.
Now, it's important to note that at some point Dopamine will cease to be delivered into the blood stream which is commonplace between 2-4 years after a relationship begins. It is, however, no coincidence that many relationships end at about the same time the chemical release runs its course.
It is also at this juncture in a relationship where married couples often claim that the "honeymoon is over". Unfortunately, when Dopamine ceases to be released, many people think that something is wrong with their relationship because they no longer feel the high of being in love, hence they tend to think that changing partners is the solution.
I believe it is fair to say that relationships will not make one happy. No, let me rephrase that: Relationships will give one a temporary boost in "hapiness", but anywhere from 2-4 years later, that chemical kick usually disappears completely and the individual is back where they started before the relationship began in terms of psychological and emotional aptitude.
This is to say that if one is a happy person before they get married, then most likely one will remain that way even after the Dopamine has subsided. Conversely, if a person is not a relatively happy individual by nature, they will typically return to a psychological and emotional base-line in short order after experiencing a temporary spike in "happiness" while the drug persisted.
What this means is that people who marry for love had better know themselves even better than the person they intend to marry. And, what people need to realize is whatever baggage they take into a relationship will still remain with them and it's not right to think that just because one doesn't feel the high of being in love any longer, that something is wrong with them, their spouse, or their marriage.
It's also true that some people mistake the effects of Dopamine for being in love and when it wears off they cannot believe what they were thinking. So, one had better marry a good person because after the love drug has worn off...you still have something to work with and something to be thankful for.
So, it is of utmost importance to be quite selective in the marriage game and not let the effects of Dopamine lead you astray. Emotions come and go, but good judgment must always have a place of honor at one's table.
My take on this issue is that The Almighty gave us Dopamine to help us bond quicker with our prospective spouse and to help facilitate the transition from oneness into the warmth and security of togetherness.
I believe it was also His intent that after a sufficient amount of time, the married couple will have been able to find a deep and abiding love for one another without the need of a chemical crutch.
In a way, Dopamine acts like the training wheels on an infant's bike, but after a little practice and with subsequent maturity, the stability of those training wheels should no longer be needed and the married couple should be able to ride off into the sunset and live happily ever after.
Hope this helps and best wishes to all. - L.R.
Ah! Romatic empassioned love! What a heady state and all too often, how destructive. In answer to the question posed by you article, yes, I'm sure every kind of relationship man can forge goes on with or without "love, whatever that really is once you take sex out of the equation. I am old now, but a little voice hardly heard and never aired (except here) wants to feel that hopeless passion again that I once had with Helen, my one and only great love.
Good article Missy, it asks the question many would like answered...Rx
Great article. Something interesting to read and ponder. Voted up.
Thank you for the kind words, Cindy, and I am glad that you found my post useful.
I wanted to give you something good after putting you through the proverbial ringer the other day. So, you may say that the above post is symbolic of a fragrant bouquet of flowers with "I'm sorry, Cindy, please forgive me" written on the card. :0)
I truly am sorry about the other day...it didn't go as planned, but I think having worked through that misunderstanding we are stronger as a result. I can already tell you that the experience has left me with a better understanding of who you are and an affection for you as a person. Thanks again and best wishes. - L.R.
Perhaps I should also mention that many people, especially women, tend to be "in love" with "being in love", and the object of their temporary obsession acts as the catalyst responsible for releasing the love drug into their blood stream which makes them feel so AMAZING.
In this regard, it is not the object of temporary obsession that this individual so craves, rather, it's the feeling they get from the chemical release they associate with their new flame.
The recipient of Dopamine does not think of it in those terms, but only knows that they love to be "in love" because it feels so good, but they assume the other party is responsible for their feelings, when, in fact, the other party may have little or nothing to do with it at all.
This is why one should allow a sufficient amount of time to pass before jumping in the sack with someone or rushing to the altar, because many people end up with "buyer's remorse" after the love drug fades-off into the sunset.
In a sense, these individuals have become addicted to the effects of Dopamine and could thusly be considered Dopamine "junkies". The down-side here is that the effects of Dopamine wears off through the passage of time, but the Dopamine junky still craves another "fix". So, if their current flame can no longer provide the "high" they are looking for, they will often seek a new "dealer" that can get them where they want to go.
I believe, Cindy, these particular individuals are the ones who tend to subscribe to the theory that a relationship just cannot work out if the couple, or one of the partners, is not "in love" with the other. And, this really is sad because these individuals are not likely to stay in a relationship long enough to appreciate and experience the benefits and virtues of mature love.
In America every 3 out of 5 marriges end in divorce and women file for divorce 75-91% of the time (depending on which studies you subcribe to). Moreover, only 10% of married couples claim to be "happily" married after 10 years.
Now, in America domestic and emotional abuse can only account for 11% of these divorces, so it is left to speculation what is responsible for the major majority of failed marriages.
I tend to think that the concept of romance, perpetual passion, and the fairy-tale courtship is found in many of the books mothers and fathers read to their little "princess" during her informative years. For many females, these fairy-tale relationships become the gold-standard and thus becomes what every little girl hopes for and dreams about...and expects to get!
It has been said that the two greatest elements that lead to unhappiness in life are unrealized and unrealistic expectations. At the end of the day, I think it is likely that these two elements are the main culprits behind most of the divorces in this country and are responsible for much of the dissatisfaction in one's life.
Better go for now, but will check back soon. Best wishes. - L.R.
I have loved and now I am in love. I spent 10 years with a person that I only loved, most likely because he was the father of my children. Now the last 13 years I have been with the person I am in love with. I still have the stars in my eyes and the butterflies my stomache when he arrives home. It is the most wonderful feeling. Nice hub, makes a lot of sense.
Really great Arcticle, i learn much more from this Arcticle.
great post loved it who lucky in love, but as friends they love each other and in many ways they are soul mates.
Truly a gift, something worth thinking about. This gives me hope in more ways than you can possibly know.
I believe couples can survive that only love each other and not be "in love". If they choose to be in a relationship like this, then they'll have to learn how to work together especially when difficulties arise.
Communication will be the biggest factor here. Knowing upfront how you are going to "deal" with one another is mandatory. It may also be helpful to know the boundaries of this kind of relationship so there is no confusion about what the other wants and expects.. this too falls under communication.
Interesting Hub!
I have been married for 25 years. Friendship and life circumstances brought my husband to me. I love him as a friend but married him and i have not been in love with him. I have never felt passion for and from him ( he says that i am love of his life), although our intimate life was good (we have 3 kids). I am very sexual and my husband does not understand this. The irony is he is a psychologist specializing in women psychology. our relationship is envy of our friends, but I have never been happy. I am considered very attractive and my husband is jealous. He uses emotional tactics to controll. When we are in public and a guy even looks at me it is my fault and he will be angry at me for that. Because of thAT we do not socialize, he separates me and our children from social life. If i have a business meeting he will not go but suggest that our son go with me. Two years ago I changed workplace and i met a guy 6 years younger than me. we fall in love to the point that we could light up the city. He tried but i never let him know how madly in love i was. I have never cheated and i never wanted to be the other woman (he is also married with kids). I was not looking for this it just happened. We had 1.5 year emotional, platonic relationship and non of us had the guts to verbalize to each other, but we both want to be together in different circumstances. he change workplace but it does not work, he still wants to know indirectly how i am. At first i thought it was lust but now i know i do love him and i am in love with him. I have never felt dis way, he is my soul mate and i cant be with him. I am in love for the first time at 46, i am connected to another human being (for 25 years my husband was trying to convince me that he cannot connect to me because of me, when in reality he was not connecting). I am depressed, i am lost, frustrated. At work I am called "power house" and nobody knows how this love affects me, but when I am home i am falling apart. My husband is very nonchalant, not affectionate ( i have no emotional support from him). he is happy when other people are miserable. I tried to give him hints, but he does not care. I look younger than my age and still have a life to live. I can solve many thing, but this. I have an advise to any man and woman: loveless relationship do not work, as spiecies we need love , affection and connection when we are with another being. I am very lonely and sensitive now. For 25 years i have been married single woman. i have no idea how to find a solution to this.
Misty thank you, what i am going through is more silent controlling emotional abuse in doses. We have a good life except for this, but unfortunatelly starts to affect every aspect that used to worked somehow. My children are all teenagers and one adult and they are very upset about this, even my sister-in-law suggested divorce. I have to consider many options before making final decision.
Hi mistyhorizon2003 I think you need to consider yourself for once and realise that you may only get one chance at life then you see whats changes in your life.
Ideal relationships are possible if both people have been in therapy for a long,long time.Everyone is defensive.This sounds like something Oprah would say in her magazines.No one is or can be honest.Many people say they love each other but don't.Many people say they hate each other but clearly they love? each other.Thats my point mistyhorizon2003 and many thanks for this nice hub
Nice tips but it helps most when both respect and love each other. The husband should make his wife equally happy too!!! Marriage takes two to make it work
yes you are wright mistyhorizon2003 loves make to eachother and both are happy and secured life.


















Pamela N Red Level 7 Commenter 5 months ago
Great story. Yes, two people can and do live together in relationships without being "in love". As you've mentioned there are arranged marriages and situations where two people marry for convenience and have fondness for each other but not the passionate love we think of when two people get married.